For years, the marketing process followed a set path: you set the strategy, you bought the media, and finally, you made the ads to fill the space. In 2026, that old order is officially broken.
The reason is simple: Platforms like Meta, Google and TikTok no longer just optimise against audiences. Their systems now analyse the creative itself, the images, the language, the emotional signals, to decide who sees your ad and how hard it’s pushed. In other words, your Creative has become a targeting signal.
The “Sameness” Trap
This matters, because brands are leaning into a sea of sameness. As generative tools make it easier to produce more content, faster, a lot of work starts to look and feel identical. When that happens, platforms treat it as “mass” content with weak signals. Costs rise, efficiency drops, and brands wonder why performance plateaus.
There’s strong evidence this isn’t just a creative preference, it’s a commercial one. Effie and System1’s The Creative Dividend analysed over 1,200 campaigns and found that creative quality and media support together explain around 60% of business results. At higher levels, the relationship becomes exponential. Campaigns with a strong “Excess Share of Creativity” were up to seven times more likely to deliver profit growth than average work .
As more brands use basic AI tools to churn out content, we’re seeing a “sea of sameness.” When everything looks and sounds identical, the algorithm treats it as “mass” content with no clear meaning. This makes your ads more expensive and less effective because the machine doesn’t know where to “point” the content.
Human Effort as a Competitive Advantage
Human work, work with emotion, distinctiveness and a clear point of view, doesn’t just perform better with people. It performs better with machines. Strong Creative gives algorithms clearer signals about who the message is for, often more effectively than manual targeting ever could.
The Big Shift for Marketing Teams
In 2026, Creative isn’t just the output of a campaign. It’s the input. This is the real shift marketing teams need to internalise. Creative choices now shape distribution, cost efficiency and learning loops before a single result comes in. This changes three specific things for marketing leaders:
- Briefing: You aren’t just briefing for an audience; you’re briefing for a “signal” that the AI can recognize.
- Testing: You need to test which creative choices help the algorithm find your best customers, not just which one gets the most clicks.
- Priority: You must prioritize distinctiveness over volume. Five high-signal ads are worth more than 500 generic ones.
In 2026, your creative choices will determine your campaign’s success long before the first result comes in. If you want to drive distribution and sales, you have to stop making “content” and start sending better signals. Or, as I (and most other Millennials) like to call them – vibes.
